Set theory seminar -Forcing axioms and inner models VI

I presented a sketch of a nice proof due to Todorcevic that {\sf PFA} implies the P-ideal dichotomy {\sf PID}. I then introduced Viale’s covering property {\sf CP} and showed that it follows from {\sf PID}. Next time I will indicate how it can be used to provide a proof of part 1 of the following theorem:

Theorem (Viale). Assume M\subseteq V is an inner model.

  1. If {\sf PFA} holds in V and M computes cardinals correctly, then it also computes correctly ordinals of cofinality \omega.
  2. If {\sf MM} holds in V, \kappa is a strong limit cardinal, (\kappa^+)^M=\kappa^+, and in M we have that \kappa is regular, then in V, the cofinality of \kappa cannot be \omega_1

It follows from this result and the last theorem from last time that if V is a model of {\sf MM} and a forcing extension of an inner model M by a cardinal preserving forcing, then {\sf ORD}^{\omega_1}\subset M.

In fact, the argument from last time shows that we can weaken the assumption that V is a forcing extension to the assumption that for all \kappa there is a regular cardinal \lambda\ge\kappa such that  in M we have a partition S^\lambda_\omega=\sqcup_{\alpha<\kappa}S_\alpha where each S_\alpha is stationary in V

It is possible that this assumption actually follows from {\sf MM} in V. However, something is required for it: In Gitik, Neeman, Sinapova, A cardinal preserving extension making the set of points of countable V cofinality nonstationary, Archive for Mathematical Logic, vol. 46 (2007), 451-456, it is shown that (assuming large cardinals) one can find a (proper class) forcing extension of V that preserves cardinals, does not add reals, and (for some cardinal \kappa) the set of points of countable V-cofinality in \lambda is nonstationary for every regular \lambda\ge\kappa^+. Obviously, this situation is incompatible with {\sf PFA} in V, by Viale’s result.

Advertisements

2 Responses to Set theory seminar -Forcing axioms and inner models VI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: